How to Negotiate Real Estate Commissions

Click here to browse our Real Estate Agent Directory and contact top-rated agents in your area!

Negotiating real estate commissions is essential to maximize your financial benefits when buying or selling a property. Understanding the structure of how agents get paid and the factors influencing an agent’s willingness to negotiate can help you make informed decisions and save thousands of dollars.

As a first-time home seller, you should know real estate commissions are often split between a listing agent and a buyer’s agent, but these rates are not set in stone. It should be made clear that real estate commissions are and have always been negotiable.

Commission negotiations vary based on local market conditions, the specific circumstances of your transaction, and the agent’s experience level. Understanding these dynamics can help you approach them strategically.

I will provide an in-depth education on the following to help you make the best decisions:

• How market conditions impact real estate commission negotiations.
• Why use the same agent for buying and selling to increase negotiating power?
• Tips for negotiating with newer versus more experienced agents.

I have been a top-producing Realtor for the past thirty-eight years. Potential clients have asked me to negotiate fees on numerous occasions. Whether I have done so has been decided on a case-by-case basis. I would never say that it is out of the question. That would be an awful business decision on my part.

Let’s examine strategies to help you better negotiate your real estate commissions.

Understanding Real Estate Commissions

It is essential to know how agents get paid.

Real estate commissions are typically calculated as a percentage of the home’s selling price. The typical rate ranges from 5% to 6% in many areas, but this can vary by region and market conditions. This commission is usually split between the listing agent (who represents the seller) and the buyer’s agent (who represents the buyer).

For example, if a home sells for $400,000 with a 6% commission rate, the total commission would be $24,000. This amount is generally divided equally between the two real estate agencies, each receiving 12,000. However, the split is often negotiated between the agents and their respective brokerages, and it may not always be a 50/50 division.

While these commission rates might seem fixed, they are often negotiable. Agents may have flexibility depending on various factors, including the local real estate market conditions, their experience, and your specific transaction.

You can see a breakdown of the average commission rates across the US.

It is essential to understand that you will be asked to sign a buyer’s agency agreement as a buyer. As a seller, you will sign a listing contract.

There Are New Ground Rules

It is also vital to know, whether a buyer or seller, that there are new rules in place regarding commissions. Here is a summary of what has changed:

• Commission rates to a buyer’s agent are no longer published in the Multiple Listing Service.
• Sellers now choose whether to offer buyer agent compensation in the MLS.
• Buyers must now sign a buyer agency agreement with an agent before viewing a property.

The Impact of Local Market Conditions

Local real estate market conditions play a crucial role in an agent’s flexibility regarding commission rates. Here’s how different market conditions can impact negotiations:

Seller’s Market

In a seller’s market, there are more buyers than available properties. Homes sell quickly, often above the asking price, with multiple offers. In these conditions, agents may be more willing to lower their commission rates to secure a quick sale.

Here’s why:

High Turnover Rates

When properties sell fast, agents can handle more transactions in a shorter period. This increased volume can compensate for slightly lower commission rates, making them more open to negotiation.

Competitive Advantage

By offering a lower commission, an agent can make a listing more attractive to potential sellers, who may choose them over other agents. When agents fight for fewer properties to market, you don’t want to miss out on opportunities.

Reduced Marketing Costs

In a hot market, homes require less marketing and advertising to attract buyers. This cost savings might give agents more room to negotiate their commission rates.

Buyer’s Market

In a buyer’s market, more homes are available than buyers. Properties tend to sit on the market longer, and sellers may have to reduce their prices or make concessions to attract buyers. Agents may be less flexible in negotiating their rates under these conditions for several reasons:

Longer Time on Market

Homes take longer to sell, so agents must invest more time, effort, and resources into marketing and negotiations. This increased workload may lead them to stick to standard commission rates.

Fewer Transactions

Overall, there are fewer transactions in a buyer’s market. Agents rely more heavily on the commissions they earn from each sale to maintain their income, making them less likely to agree to lower rates.

Higher Costs

Marketing a home in a slower market typically involves more extensive and expensive strategies, such as open houses, online advertising, and staging. A real estate agent does many things, and these factors have to be considered. Given these additional costs, agents may be reluctant to reduce their rates.

You Have More Leverage With Buying and Selling Simultaneously

When a client buys and sells a home simultaneously, it creates two transactions for an agent. This is a desirable situation for an agent. As a consumer, you should take advantage of this situation by negotiating a lower commission schedule.

How This Situation Can Help You Negotiate

Increased Earnings Potential for the Agent

When an agent represents both sides, they stand to earn a commission from both the sale and the purchase. This dual-earning potential can incentivize the agent to lower their rate, as they still benefit from two commissions.

Simplified Negotiations

Working with a single agent can streamline the negotiation process. The agent may be more willing to lower their commission to ensure both sides of the transaction go smoothly, particularly if they’re eager to close quickly.

Opportunity for Concessions

You can ask the agent for a concession on the commission rate, pointing out the benefits they receive from managing both transactions. This could result in a reduced commission or other favorable terms.

I can tell you under this circumstance, I have never turned down the request for a lower rate. Doing so would be like cutting off your nose to spite your face.

But plenty of real estate agents make bad business decisions. They will take the chance of having nothing rather than having a little bit less. Don’t feel bad going elsewhere if you encounter one of these agents.

Negotiating with Newer vs. Experienced Agents

An agent’s experience level can significantly impact their willingness to negotiate real estate commission rates. Understanding these dynamics can help you tailor your negotiation strategy effectively.

Newer Agents

Newer agents who are just starting in the industry may be more willing to negotiate commission rates to build their client base and gain experience.

Here’s why:

Building a Portfolio

New agents are often eager to build a portfolio of successful sales. They may be more inclined to offer a reduced commission to secure your business and create a track record of satisfied clients.

Attracting Clients

To stand out in a competitive market, newer agents may offer lower rates or additional services, such as enhanced marketing or staging, at no extra cost. This approach helps them compete against more established agents.

Flexibility and Availability

Newer agents may have fewer clients and more time to dedicate to your transaction. This increased availability can make them more amenable to negotiation as they aim to establish their reputation and secure referrals.

Experienced Agents

More experienced agents, on the other hand, might be less flexible with their commission rates because they understand their value and the comprehensive services they provide.

Here’s how to approach negotiations with them:

Highlight Potential Referrals

Experienced agents rely heavily on referrals from satisfied clients. If you have a network of potential clients, use this as leverage in your negotiations. Explain that a lower commission rate could lead to multiple future transactions.

Emphasize Multiple Transactions

Consider using the same experienced agent for buying and selling transactions. This approach can give the agent two commissions, increasing their incentive to negotiate a lower rate.

Point Out the Market Dynamics

Even experienced agents must adapt to market conditions. Highlight how local trends could impact their business and suggest that a lower commission rate might lead to faster transactions and more future business.

Tips to Successfully Negotiate Real Estate Commissions

Negotiating real estate commissions can feel daunting, but with the right approach, you can improve your chances of securing a better rate. Here are some detailed tips:

Do Your Research:

• Understand the typical commission rates in your area. Research recent sales and ask friends or neighbors about their experiences.
• Use this data to make a compelling case when negotiating. Knowing the standard rates and recent trends shows you are informed and serious.

Highlight the Market Conditions:

• Leverage local market conditions to support your negotiation. In a seller’s market, emphasize that a quick sale requires less effort and marketing expense from the agent.
• In a buyer’s market, stress the importance of closing deals quickly to avoid extended marketing costs. This perspective can help frame your request for a lower rate.

Propose Dual Transactions:

• If you’re both buying and selling, suggest using the same agent for both transactions. This dual opportunity can make agents more willing to negotiate their commission rates for each deal.
• Highlight how handling both transactions reduces the agent’s marketing efforts, simplifies coordination, and potentially leads to faster closings.

Consider the Agent’s Experience Level:

• Tailor your approach based on the agent’s experience. With newer agents, emphasize your willingness to provide referrals or reviews in exchange for a reduced rate.
• With experienced agents, focus on the potential for future business and how a competitive rate could lead to more transactions.

Communicate Clearly and Professionally:

• Approach negotiations respectfully. Begin the conversation by expressing interest in working together and understanding the agent’s value.
• Clearly outline your reasons for requesting a lower Realtor commission rate, backing up your case with facts, market trends, and a focus on mutual benefits. Be prepared for a counteroffer and remain open to compromise.

Conclusion

To successfully negotiate real estate commissions, it’s crucial to understand the local market conditions and tailor your strategy to the agent’s experience level. Remember, there are many challenges to selling a home, so you will want someone in your corner who can easily handle problems.

By leveraging these factors, you can enhance your chances of achieving a favorable commission rate and save money on your real estate transactions.