Cheapest Cities to Rent in Indiana

If you’re planning to move to Indiana, relocating within the state, or considering an investment in real estate, you’ll find our list of the most affordable cities to rent in Indiana valuable. This guide will help you navigate the diverse rental market in the Hoosier State.

Indiana is well-regarded for its heartland charm, scenic beauty, and strong sense of community. According to US News, it possesses a robust economy and ranks commendably in higher education nationwide. Given these benefits, it’s easy to see why Indiana is a favored destination for many.

The state’s rental market reflects its size and diversity. Over recent years, Indiana has seen a steady increase in population, largely due to its affordable cost of living, lively city cultures, and diverse job opportunities.

While the demand for affordable rentals is high, not all cities in Indiana can be classified as cheap. However, there are areas where the average rent is notably lower than in the rest of the state. Continue reading to discover which cities offer the best rental deals in Indiana.

Indiana Rental Statistics

Before we dive into the most affordable cities to rent in Indiana, let’s look at a few general rental facts and statistics:

• The average rent in Indiana is $850 per month, compared to $2,016 nationwide
• Across the U.S., rental rates have increased by 31% in the past ten years
• Approximately 109 million Americans reside in rental housing
• The state with the highest number of rental units is California
• About 24.8% of households in Indiana rent their homes, with a rental vacancy rate of 8.8%

It’s clear that Indiana is a more affordable living option than the national average and presents attractive opportunities for renters and real estate investors alike.

From an investment perspective, the strong demand for rental housing, coupled with below-average rental rates and a moderate rental vacancy rate, positions Indiana as a promising market. Real estate investors can potentially reap significant returns by providing affordable housing options to the sizable percentage of Hoosiers who prefer to rent.

Cheapest Cities to Rent in Indiana

This list of the most affordable cities to rent in Indiana does not just focus on rental prices alone. We’re taking a comprehensive approach, examining various factors contributing to the overall cost of living and quality of life in each city. This includes:

• Population: The size of the city’s population can impact the availability and pricing of rental properties.
• Median Home Listing Price: This gives us a sense of the overall real estate market in the city.
• Average Number of Days on the Market: This helps us understand how quickly properties are rented or sold.
• Median Household Income: This figure offers a glimpse into the earning potential in the area.
• Average Rent Price: Most crucial to our analysis, this tells us the typical cost of renting in the city.

Whether you’re a potential renter seeking the most value for your money or an investor scouting for high-return opportunities, our analysis will provide the insights you need to explore these affordable Indiana rental markets.

Here are the top ten cheapest cities to rent in Indiana, let’s dive in!

1. Fort Wayne

• Population: 265,974
• Median home listing price: $285,000
• Average number of days on the market: 16 days
• Median household income: $53,978
• Average rent price: $693

As Indiana’s second-largest city, Fort Wayne has a lot to offer. Known for its active community, it hosts many festivals and events throughout the year.

The city’s bustling downtown is home to various restaurants, boutiques, and cultural attractions, like the Embassy Theatre and Parkview Field. The city’s rich history can be explored in its beautifully restored historic neighborhoods and public parks.

Fort Wayne is also home to a thriving economy, anchored by the healthcare, retail, and manufacturing sectors.

2. Evansville

• Population: 116,486
• Median home listing price: $225,500
• Average number of days on the market: 16 days
• Median household income: $45,649
• Average rent price: $702

Evansville, situated on the Ohio River, is the third-largest city in Indiana and offers residents a mix of metropolitan and rural lifestyles.

The city boasts a strong economy based in manufacturing, healthcare, and education. Its historic downtown district is home to several attractions, such as the Evansville Museum of Arts, History & Science, and the Tropicana Evansville Casino.

The city also enjoys natural beauty with its Riverfront and numerous parks, which offer excellent outdoor activities.

3. Muncie

• Population: 65,292
• Median home listing price: $123,000
• Average number of days on the market: 24 days
• Median household income: $47,966
• Average rent price: $705

Muncie is a small city with a lot of character. It is home to Ball State University, which brings a youthful energy and fosters an environment of innovation and education.

The city boasts a range of cultural attractions, including the David Owsley Museum of Art and Minnetrista, a cultural center with beautiful gardens and exhibits.

The Muncie Civic Theatre provides local entertainment, and the city’s numerous parks and trails offer plenty of opportunities for outdoor recreation.

4. Greenwood

• Population: 64,918
• Median home listing price: $358,900
• Average number of days on the market: 29 days
• Median household income: $71,159
• Average rent price: $770

Just a few miles south of Indianapolis, Greenwood offers the perks of suburban life with the convenience of a nearby metropolis.

The city is known for its friendly community, strong school system, and numerous parks and recreation centers. Its vibrant downtown features a range of shopping, dining, and entertainment options.

Greenwood’s annual Freedom Festival, complete with a parade and fireworks, embodies the city’s strong community spirit.

5. South Bend

• Population: 103,353
• Median home listing price: $189,000
• Average number of days on the market: 18 days
• Median household income: $46,002
• Average rent price: $777

South Bend, the fourth-largest city in Indiana, is probably best known as the home of the University of Notre Dame.

However, the city offers more than just a college town atmosphere, with a thriving arts scene, a buzzing downtown area filled with restaurants, and various local businesses. With the St. Joseph River flowing through, the city has beautiful riverfront views and parks.

South Bend also has a rich history, visible in its preserved architectural buildings and museums.

6. West Lafayette

• Population: 44,672
• Median home listing price: $399,900
• Average number of days on the market: 11 days
• Median household income: $31,460
• Average rent price: $797

West Lafayette is another college town in Indiana, home to Purdue University, which drives its economy and contributes to its cultural and intellectual richness.

The city offers a range of outdoor activities, from exploring the Celery Bog Nature Area to walking along the Wabash Heritage Trail.

West Lafayette also has an exciting food scene, with an eclectic mix of local and international cuisine.

7. Kokomo

• Population: 59,691
• Median home listing price: $149,900
• Average number of days on the market: 24 days
• Median household income: $51,450
• Average rent price: $813

Kokomo is a city that values its history, visible in its beautiful historic downtown, which is a hub of local businesses, restaurants, and arts venues.

Known as the “City of Firsts” for its automotive history, Kokomo offers various museums and historical sites.

Kokomo Reservoir, the Wildcat Creek, and numerous parks also provide excellent outdoor recreation opportunities.

8. Mishawaka

• Population: 51,074
• Median home listing price: $197,000
• Average number of days on the market: 15 days
• Median household income: $48,695
• Average rent price: $935

Mishawaka, known as “the Princess City,” is located on the St. Joseph River. The city features a charming downtown area with unique shops, restaurants, and breweries.

The Riverwalk winds along the river and offers beautiful scenic views and recreational opportunities.

Additionally, Mishawaka is known for its excellent schools, making it an attractive choice for families.

9. Lafayette

• Population: 70,835
• Median home listing price: $269,900
• Average number of days on the market: 11 days
• Median household income: $46,925
• Average rent price: $971

Lafayette, across the Wabash River from its sister city, West Lafayette, is a vibrant city with a rich history.

It offers various cultural and recreational activities, from the Art Museum of Greater Lafayette to the Columbian Park Zoo.

The city’s historic Nine Square district is home to various boutiques, restaurants, and galleries, providing an eclectic mix of shopping and dining experiences.

10. Columbus

• Population: 50,569
• Median home listing price: $345,000
• Average number of days on the market: 29 days
• Median household income: $72,380
• Average rent price: $982

Columbus is a small city with an outsized reputation for architecture and design, earning it the nickname “Athens of the Prairie.”

The city offers a rich cultural experience with numerous architectural landmarks, art installations, and a thriving downtown area.

It also boasts a strong economy, primarily based on manufacturing, and provides a high standard of living for its residents.

>> DISCOVER: Cheapest Cities to Rent in Arizona

Final Thoughts

Which cheapest city to rent in Indiana is calling you? All of these cities have thriving communities, healthy real estate markets, and strong economies. Whether you’re looking for a city steeped in history, a vibrant arts scene, or strong economic opportunities, Indiana has a city for you.

Ready to rent in one of the cheapest cities in Indiana? 

If you’re looking to explore these communities further and see if investing in property in one of these cities is right for you, we invite you to reach out to FastExpert.com. As a company that connects people buying or selling a home with top real estate agents, we can match you with the perfect real estate agent who understands your motivation for investing in Indiana.

We make it easy for you to hire the right real estate agent, and we provide convenient options to easily compare top agents to simplify your selection. Give us a try and discover why over 400,000 happy clients choose FastExpert!