Service Areas
About Trish Schaefer
Specialties
- Sellers
- Buyers
- Residential Property
- Commercial Property
Awards
-
2025
TOP AGENT
Sun Prairie, WI
2025
TOP AGENT
Watertown, WI
2025
TOP AGENT
Waunakee, WI
Recent Sales
We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:
- 1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
- 2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.
Trish Schaefer's Reviews & Ratings
- Knowledgeable
- Responsive
- Professional
- Communicative
- Attentive
- Outstanding
- Great for new buyers
- Hard working
- Trustworthy
Jpchamberlin
Trish and the rest of the crew at American Realtors was absolutely wonderful throughout the process of selling our home and buying a new one. We were well-supported at every stage of the process, all of our questions were answered, and we got tons of great advice. Even when there were setbacks, Trish and kept our wishes in mind and took such good care of us. We couldn't have asked for a more knowledgeable, more friendly, and more helpful realtor.
Mkatawczik
Working with Trish was a great experience. Hands down the best Real Estate professional we have ever worked with. Knowledgeable about the area, houses in general, she knew what to look for and warn against. Very responsive no matter what the time of day. If we ever have to buy or sell our house in the area again she would be our choice.
Jsdouglas33
Trish and her associate Deb did 2 times in a 41/2 year period that multiple Realitors could do . The first property was listed for 2 summers with other Realitors, contacted Trish and came out and evaluated the property and said its not being shown at an appropriate price. Trish raised the price of the 150000. And had a contract in 7 days .This last house sold in less than 40 days and it was located an hour from anywhere. Trish and Deb marketed it to cater to the home and capitalized on locations around it on top of all the features the home offered. Trisha and Deb are top notch Realitors that look , listen, and evaluate each property as if it was there own on the market . If you want first class professional Realitors and dont want to sell yourself short then Trish and Deb are outstanding and who you need.
Garbageguy21
Trish and staff were just awesome! A lot has changed in the 30+ years since selling and buying a house, and they helped immensely with the on-line paperwork processing. Trish is a proponent of the "value range" listing pricing whereas the other realtors we talked to were leery of it and put a substantially lower listing on their quotes. Not only did we get offers from the first two showings, but sold and closed the house at the top of the price range that Trish suggested. I understand that a complex undertaking as buying and selling real estate is can have its challenges, but the few we incurred were handled quickly and professionally. This all occurred during the peak of the Covid situation!
Lnechuta
Trish was very responsive to text messages/calls at all hours of the day when I found a house I wanted to set up a showing for. If she for some reason could not attend a showing due to unexpected conflict she was prompt in sending her associate, Deb, to meet me. Both her and Deb were helpful in assisting me in my home search and during the closing process when purchasing my first home.
More Agents Near You









