0
Sue Mitchell and Erin Casey Top real estate agent in Tustin

Sue Mitchell and Erin Casey

Sur West Homes
34 Years of Experience
(72)
$23.5M
Total Sales Last Year
34
Years of Experience
49
Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years
$1.5M
Average Price Point
  • Service Areas
  • About
  • Credentials
  • Recent Sales
  • Contact Information
  • Social Media
  • Specialities
  • Awards

Service Areas

View All Service Areas

About Sue Mitchell and Erin Casey

Sue Mitchell began selling Coastal properites at the beach in 1991! She moved to North Tustin in 1996 and rekindled her love of real estate by starting her own brokerage, Sur West Homes in 2010. She has successfully handled everything from the purchase and sale of single family starter homes to high end residences. Prior to entering real estate Sue was a Certified Public Accountant with KPMG Peat Marwick. She also worked as a corporate controller and finance manager for both a commercial builder and a large Southern California home builder where she gained insight into construction, lending and sales and marketing. Sue worked at Prudential California Realty's Newport Beach office where she was consistently ranked in the Top 10 and received the Presidents Award numerous times. Sue has sold dozens of homes in the beach areas of Corona del Mar and Newport Beach, Costa Mesa and throughout Tustin and North Tustin. She has handled relocation, short sales, helped her clients with loan modifications, 1031 exchanges, and provided leasing and property management services. In addition, Sue has an extensive network of realtors throughout CA and the country and can help her clients find outstanding real estate services anywhere. Erin's passion for real estate began while working for the Los Angeles Times and is strengthened by her extensive experience in sales. Her interest continued as her husband, a custom home builder in Orange County, built properties in North Tustin, Shady Canyon, and Newport Coast. Enthusiastic attention to detail blends with her great follow-up and organizational skills to offer you just the right combination you have been looking for in an agent, whether representing you as a buyer or seller. Having lived in North Tustin most of her life, married to her husband, Tim, for over 30 years, now with two grown sons. Connor lives in NYC and graduated from Ohio State and Ryan graduated from Boston University and lives in Newport Beach. Life is busy... but whose isn't? With a daily addiction to exercise and a love for baking and travel Erin and Tim lead an active lifestyle.They love traveling and adventures in dining as well as staying involved with family, local charities and sports, and enjoying life!
Community Involvement
Foothill High School sports, Dino Dash, Marys Path, Assitance League of Tustin
HOBBIES/INTEREST
work out, travel, bake and garden!
FAMILY
We each have grown kids raised in North Tustin.
Read More About Sue

Credentials

LICENSE
Real Estate - California - # 01110196
Designation

CPA, SRES

Specialties

  • Sellers
  • Buyers
  • Residential Property

Awards

  • award image
  • rewards

    2025

    TOP AGENT

    Santa Ana, CA

  • rewards

    2025

    TOP AGENT

    Tustin, CA

Other Awards

Zillow premier agent

View All Awards

Recent Sales

Showing 4 out of 73

We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:

  1. 1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
  2. 2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.
Date
Address
Price
Represented
12/11/2024
520 N Blvd APT 1 Brea, CA 92821
Sold For $500K
12/11/2024 Seller
11/26/2024
309 Alta Ln Costa Mesa, CA 92627
Sold For $830K
11/26/2024 Seller
11/04/2024
13 Via Jacobea San Clemente, CA 92673
Sold For $2.1M
11/04/2024 Buyer
10/09/2024
17412 Village Dr Tustin, CA 92780
Sold For $1.8M
10/09/2024 Seller

Sue Mitchell and Erin Casey's Reviews & Ratings

72 Reviews
(5/5)
Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
  • Responsive
  • Knowledgeable
  • Professional
  • Communicative
  • Trustworthy
  • Outstanding
  • Attentive
  • Excellent negotiator
  • Hard working
  • Great for new buyers

Janie G

Review for Member: Janie G
September 15, 2022
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

We had such a great experience working with Erin and Sue. Our first offer was accepted, and they negotiated a price reduction even though the seller had an inspection already done and sale was as is. They also helped us by recommending contractors for a few items we needed done prior to moving in. They were both so professional and on top of every detail from start to finish. Moving forward I will recommend every buyer I know to them. We are so excited for our next chapter in this home and we owe it all to them!

Opremarina0

Review for Member: Opremarina0
August 15, 2022
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

We were moving to California from Utah, lucky for us we came across an open house that Sue and Erin were hosting. They were willing to help us and they werent even our agents. Needless to say I decided to hire them instead. Their kindness , and knowledge of the California market was amazing. They spent endless hours driving around to find the perfect home. Always being so positive that we would find the right house. On our last weekend that we came out they found us that perfect home. Everyone had told us that the chance of getting the first house we try for was slim to nothing. Well they were wrong, these two ladies made it happen?? Truly We feel so lucky that we got to work with Erin and Sue , they worked so hard to make sure we were happy and still check in on us today to see if we need anything. Thank you again Erin and Sue.

Andylawrencedawson

Review for Member: Andylawrencedawson
July 30, 2022
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

We can't recommend Sue and Erin highly enough! Sur West sold our home in North Tustin last year and secured an incredible result for us, so when the time came a few months back to sell my in-laws' home in Costa Mesa that needed some TLC after 40+ years of ownership, it was a no brainer to make Sur West our first and only call. And despite raising interest rates and inflation, they guided us through the listing and selling process seamlessly and delivered a great result again. Sue and Erin make it so easy!

Echelberry8

Review for Member: Echelberry8
July 27, 2022
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

Working with Sue and Erin was the most efficient and pleasant real estate experience weve had in the last two decades. Before we engaged them, we evaluated multiple firms, including some of the most familiar companies in our area. We chose Sue and Erin because they brought a level of commitment and personalized service that no other team offered. Sue and Erin explained every step of the process to market and sell our property with great detail and patience. The executed in a timely and professional manner, navigating the volatile market to our best advantage. Thanks to their experience and dedication, we closed in short order with no hiccups. We will definitely use them to sell our other properties and recommend you do the same!

Becky027

Review for Member: Becky027
July 26, 2022
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

When we decided to sell what we thought would be our forever home to move out of state there was no doubt in our minds about selecting Sue and Erin to represent us with our real estate needs. Having worked with them in the past we knew the top notch professionalism, attention to detail, responsiveness, and knowledge of the local market that they have. Sue and Erin are both so personable and kind, but don't let that fool you, they know their stuff up and down and will be your best advocate to get you the best deal possible. We knew the market was beginning to soften with the recent rise in interest rates so we wanted to get our house on the market asap. Sue and Erin quickly set the wheels in motion to make sure we had what we needed to have our house in perfect showing condition. They quickly scheduled everything needed, window washing, professional staging, photos/video and got our house on the market in record time. It ended up being an extremely warm weekend for open house so they hired an ice cream cart for potential buyers to enjoy in the backyard :) Our home was marketed so well that we had multiple over asking offers within 3 days, were under contract within the first week, closed in 30 days a with a deal that allowed us to stay in the house for an additional 2 weeks rent free until our son finished out his baseball season. Hands down Sue & Erin are the best real estate agents in town. They went above and beyond, anticipated needs and met them all with a smile on their face and expert advice. They were an absolute pleasure to work with and made the selling of our home seamless. We are incredibly grateful that they were our realtors and we will always highly recommend Sue & Erin to our friends and family.

Contact Information

Location

2913 El Camino Real #105 Tustin Tustin, CA, 92782

Social Media

Trusted Professionals

Trusted Pro

Sue Mitchell and Erin Casey is a Trusted Pro with a network of verified professionals.

Kevin Mckee

Title Rep

More Agents Near You

Chris Cooke
(68 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2006
Berkshire Hathaway Homesale Realty
533 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
Nisha Smithrick
(0 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2006
NextHome Forward
47 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
Kathy Banaszewski
(164 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2005
Real Estate Professionals, Inc. REALTORS
100 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
James Weiskerger
(458 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2002
Next Step Realty
91 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
Brian Dinardo
(60 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2001
Garner and Co
48 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
Victor Dominguez
(0 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2018
EXP Realty LLC
2 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
Elizabeth Ancel
(106 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2008
Cummings & Co Realtors
87 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
Michael Frank
(80 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2013
eXp Realty, 811
83 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
Chris Drewer
(203 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2004
EXP Realty
80 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile
John Maranto
(60 reviews)
Licensed Since: 2006
Cummings and Company
79 sales in Baltimore, MD
View Profile