Service Areas
About Starr Keating
Specialties
- Sellers
- Buyers
- Residential Property
Awards
-
2025
TOP AGENT
Fleming Island, FL
2025
TOP AGENT
Orange Park, FL
2025
TOP AGENT
Middleburg, FL
Recent Sales
We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:
- 1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
- 2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.
Starr Keating's Reviews & Ratings
- Professional
- Responsive
- Knowledgeable
- Communicative
- Outstanding
- Attentive
- Hard working
- Trustworthy
- Great for new buyers
- Available Remotely
Sherri Howard
ZillowVERIFIEDStarr and Alayna are true professionals. Their expertise and commitment was invaluable. From the beginning with the latest technology to the effective marketing tools. They went over and above making our transaction as stress free as possible. We highly recommend them!
Ang64wilson
ZillowVERIFIEDStarr and Alayna have represented us in both buying in 2016 and selling our home in 2024. Their knowledge, enthusiasm and professionalism are amazing. Their communication as a team gave us peace of mind and they made sure we were prepared for all possibilities and transactions. We had a very positive outcome and would recommend them for your home search or sale!
Judyhois04
ZillowVERIFIEDStarr was the listing agent for the home we recently purchased. Weve had to reach out to Starr to assist with removing information from the internet. We have numerous communication evidences of lack of response. Additionally she told our agent we had to make the requests to MLS. There is one item that requires her to assistance and she has aEURoeghosted usaEUR?. This is not professional nor what anyone should want in an agent. I would never work with Starr and team again, the unfortunate part is she was this listing agent for a home we purchased. So we were forced to work with her.
Julie Robbins
ZillowVERIFIEDAlayna Summanen is an outstanding realtor who is very kind, knowledgeable, and goes above and beyond. A mutual friend connected me with Alayna when we decided we wanted to move aEURoehomeaEUR? from AZ. Weve bought many houses and have had many realtors over the years but none compare to Alayna. Even when she was out of town, Starr was there to help as needed. They are a great team! The sellers realtor was slow to respond but Alayna was constantly on top of things and pushing for a successful transaction from start to finish. She always made time to do video tours or a walk thru with our family as we could not make it to FL to see the houses in person. We cannot thank her enough for making what is a stressful (and exciting) time more manageable!
Ellenandbrad6494
ZillowVERIFIED"Starr Keating and Alayna Summanen at Coldwell Banker did an incredible job selling our home and helping us purchase another one. The communication was above expectations and their advice paid us back in spades. They kept us informed and we always knew what was expected and when it was needed. It was the best experience I could ask for. In fact, when our home first went on the market; they were scheduled to be out of the country. We were given a contact person in the office here but that made no difference to them as they still called and sent texts the entire time. Amazing dedication to the client! When I would go to open houses I would proudly announce to the agent on duty that Starr and Alayna were my realtors and on one such visit the agent responded, "They are legends in the business!" Oh don't let me forget the excellent staging and the references they provided. The process was seamless and for that to be the case for two homes is exceptional. I have a third home that I am getting ready for the market and I know exactly who I will ask to be our realtor, The Starr Team. Thank you all so very much! "
