Service Areas
About Laurel Lustgarten
Specialties
- Sellers
- Buyers
- Residential Property
Awards
-
2025
TOP AGENT
Middletown, NY
2025
TOP AGENT
Monroe, NY
2025
TOP AGENT
Montgomery, NY
Other Awards
Hudson Valley Magazine - "Meet the Hudson Valley's Top Realtors" list - 2023, Hanna | Rand Realty Legend Award- 2022, Howard Hanna | Rand Realty Best of the Best Award - 2022,
Loading recent sales...
Laurel Lustgarten's Reviews & Ratings
- Professional
- Knowledgeable
- Communicative
- Responsive
- Trustworthy
- Outstanding
- Attentive
- Hard working
- Available Remotely
- Great for new buyers
Catherine V.
Laurel Lustgarten is a fantastic real estate agent. She sold my house in record time, and held my hand through the staging, the negotiations and the messy closing. Laurel fixed other people's mistakes, and saw to my best interests, Laurel treated me "special" even though my house was not a million dollar deal. I am recommending her services to all my friends.
Alexis M.
Laurel was amazing from start to finish. She knew the market and priced our house accordingly. Not only did we get asking but 30k above. We were more than pleased, every thing went smoothly from start to finish. Her expertise was invaluable.
Jay E.
I cannot speak highly enough of Laurel. She is exceptionally knowledgeable and a true expert in her field. Laurel is consistently responsive to emails, texts, and inquiries of any kind, regardless of the time or complexity of the question. Laurel did not rush us at any point during the process, always giving honest feedback and we saw a lot of properties at all hours. For full transparency, we worked with Laurel when purchasing our first home in 2015 and reached out to her again in 2025, unsure of what to expect after so many years. Her patience, professionalism, thoughtful guidance, and genuine care for her clients were evident throughout the entire process. She took the time to walk us through every step of the home-buying journey, from the initial consultation to the closing table. I highly recommend Laurel and her team to both first-time and repeat buyers. Professionals who deliver this level of service and customer care are increasingly rare. Our family is truly grateful for her support and expertise.
Amy B.
I cant say enough great things about Laurel! From start to finish she went above and beyond in every aspect of selling my home. Her work ethic is truly unmatched! She is always available, always in communication and always one step ahead. I never once felt out of the loop and her guidance through each stage of the process was invaluable. What stood out the most was her professionalism and genuine dedication. She worked incredibly hard to make the sale as smooth and successful as possible. I am deeply appreciative of all her efforts, expertise, and support. I highly recommend Laurel if youre looking for an agent who puts in the extra effort and truly delivers!
Zuser20150406152238231
We had the absolute best experience working with Laurel Lustgarten! As first-time home buyers, we had a lot of questions and uncertainties, but Laurel was incredibly patient, knowledgeable, and always available to explain every detail clearly. She made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and manageable. We hit a few bumps along the way aEUR" another offer came in right before we went under contract, some issues popped up during the inspection, and even the final walk-through had surprises aEUR" but Laurel was on top of everything from start to finish. She went above and beyond to advocate for us, even writing a thoughtful email to the sellers explaining why they should stick with our offer. Thanks to her professionalism, persistence, and care, we ended up in our dream home. We cant recommend Laurel highly enough. If youre buying or selling a home, especially if its your first time, you definitely want her on your side!

