Amy Prumo

Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co

15 Years of Experience

(26)

$25M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$428.5K

Average Price Point

Service Areas
Intro Video
About
Recent Sales
Contact Information
Social Media
Specialities
Awards

Service Areas

Big Pine Key, FL Islamorada, FL Key Colony Beach, FL Long Key, FL Marathon Shores, FL Marathon, FL Summerland Key, FL Tavernier, FL

View All Service Areas

About Amy Prumo

Amy is a Florida Keys Elite Agent & Diamond Award Winner. She has been selling real estate for over 13 years in the keys. Before her career in real estate, Amy implemented and developed various marketing and sales strategies for companies in Upstate New York and Florida. She holds a Master's Degree in Marketing and Management. Tom's experience is in the Building, Planning, Zoning and Development field. He worked in the Civil Engineering Department for the USAF. He was the Building Official/Director of Building Planning and Zoning for a municipality for over ten years; and is the owner of Alliance Custom Builders. He also holds twenty licenses through the International Code counsel.

HOBBIES/INTEREST

Cooking, Swimming, Shopping

Specialties

Sellers
Buyers
Mobile Homes

Awards

2025
TOP AGENT
Marathon, FL
2025
TOP AGENT
Key Colony Beach, FL
2025
TOP AGENT
Big Pine Key, FL

View All Awards

Recent Sales

Showing 4 out of 99

We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:

1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.

Date

Address

Price

Represented

09/26/2024

97 Coco Plum Dr #T-7 Marathon, FL 33050

Sold For $265K

09/26/2024 Both

09/09/2024

22819 Blackbeard Ln Summerland Key, FL 33042

Sold For $200K

09/09/2024 Both

09/04/2024

696 W 105th St Marathon, FL 33050

Sold For $657.5K

09/04/2024 Seller

07/02/2024

201 7th St UNIT 3 Key Colony Beach, FL 33051

Sold For $235K

07/02/2024 Buyer

Amy Prumo's Reviews & Ratings

26 Reviews

(5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Responsive
Attentive
Communicative
Excellent negotiator
Knowledgeable
Outstanding
Professional

Nashd390

Review for Member: Nashd390

September 15, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

WOW! Amy and Tom are great. They helped us sell our lots and made the whole process super easy! Excellent communication, awesome marketing techniques too! I would highly recommend them for real estate in the Florida Keys.

Lvman1243

Review for Member: Lvman1243

September 15, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

The best Florida Keys Real Estate Agents. Amy and Tom did a wonderful job helping us sell our property in Marathon. They went above and beyond, their service was top notch. Thank you for getting our home sold and helping us with our life goals.

Kevinph790

Review for Member: Kevinph790

January 25, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Amy & Tom are Fantastic. They are the go to realtors of the Middle Keys Area. They know all the local in and outs and were able to sell my property quick and for top dollar. Amy's marketing was awesome. From 3D tours, to video walk throughs they made sure to get the most eyes on MY Property. Excellent job throughout the whole process. We use them both again.