Home›Advice›Finance & Legal Info›Can an agent enforce payment of non mandatory POA dues?
Go Back

Can an agent enforce payment of non mandatory POA dues?

My community has a POA. Our covenants have no mandatory dues written or listed anywhere in them. Our POA board interchanges the use of HOA/POA terminology to illicit mandatory dues from property owners selling their homes and land. The POA a few years back hired a property management company who were also real estate agents to manage the financial side of the association. In doing so they were given a set of bylaws stating the association had mandatory dues. These bylaws did not align themselves to our covenants. Anyone not paying those annual dues were told they would have to pay when selling their property at closing. The management company shared this information with all the other realtor groups in the county. Also, informing title companies there was a transfer fee to be paid by seller at time of closing. If the seller refused to pay any " outstanding" fees the sale of property could /would be jeopardized and risked the sale not going through. This situation is illegal, the covenants do not subscribe to mandatory fees of any description in the entirety of the document, and therfore real estate companies have no right to enforce this and should stop demanding this from sellers. How can we stop real-estate agents giving potential buyers false information about mandatory dues and transfer fees, and forcing sellers to pay for fees that are not mandatory?

Asked by Fiona Vaughan | Sevierville, TN| 10-21-2024| 499 views|Finance & Legal Info|Updated 2 years ago

While AI use is allowed, don't copy & paste generic answers. Add your own insights and real experience to make your answer personal and helpful.

Sort by:

Expert answers are from licensed real estate professionals with a verified FastExpert profile.

Eli CorumReal Estate Agent1 month ago
Rising Star22 Answers

An agent cannot invent a lien power that the recorded covenants do not give the association. Start with the documents that run with the land: the recorded covenants and any amendments, not a management company’s bylaws handout. If dues are not mandatory in the covenants, a seller’s agent should not treat unpaid “voluntary” assessments like a hard closing condition without clear authority. Practical next step: have a Tennessee real estate attorney read the covenants, bylaws, and any demand letter. Ask in writing what exact document creates the obligation and whether it was properly recorded. Title and closing teams care about recorded encumbrances, not marketing language that swaps HOA and POA labels. If you are selling near Sevierville and the POA is blocking a clean closing story, get counsel involved early so your listing calendar does not stall. Happy to help you sort what belongs in the listing file versus what needs an attorney. Next Door Real Estate Group. Eli Corum, Next Door Real Estate Group

Find Agent CTA

Are you ready to find a top agent near you?

Browse profiles of the highest ranked agents in your area and find one that meets your specific needs.

Michael AtkinsonReal Estate Agent2 months ago

Fiona, this really needs review by a Tennessee real estate attorney. An agent or management company shouldn’t independently determine whether dues are legally enforceable. Have an attorney review the recorded covenants, bylaws and any amendments and, if appropriate, formally notify the association, management company and title companies of the issue.

Zoltan PeresztegiReal Estate Agent3 months ago

The governing principle is simple, and it is in your favor: an association's power to charge you money has to come from a recorded instrument that runs with your land. If your recorded covenants contain no assessment authority, a board generally cannot manufacture it by vote, by bylaw, by hiring a management company, or by starting to call itself an HOA instead of a POA. A few concepts worth naming, because they are the ones that decide this. Covenants run with the land only as recorded. What binds you, and every future owner of your parcel, is the declaration recorded in the county land records. Not what the board says at a meeting, and not the bylaws. Bylaws govern internal operations. They do not create monetary obligations on land. Amendment is a procedure, not a decision. Most declarations contain their own amendment clause, typically requiring a supermajority of owners plus recording. A board cannot unilaterally add a new financial obligation. Courts in several states have been skeptical of amendments that impose an entirely new category of burden on owners who never agreed to one. Voluntary associations are real and common. Plenty of older subdivisions have one that maintains a sign, a road, or a lake on donated dues. That is legitimate. What is not legitimate is a voluntary association asserting lien rights it never had. Now the practical part, because I suspect this is what you are running into. At closing, the title company will not insure over a claimed lien or unpaid assessment. So the association's real leverage is not litigation, it is clouding title at the moment you are most vulnerable, when you have a buyer, a rate lock, and a moving truck. That is why sellers pay disputed POA demands. It is not evidence the demand was valid. What I would do, in this order. - Pull a title search and read the recorded declaration front to back. Not a summary, the recorded document with book and page. Look for any assessment or lien language. - Send a certified written demand for the specific recorded provision that authorizes the assessment, plus the governing documents, any recorded amendment they rely on, and the minutes authorizing the charge. Many states give owners a statutory right to inspect association records, and a written demand builds the record you will need later. - Confirm what, if anything, is actually recorded against your parcel. A demand letter is not a lien. - Hire a real estate attorney licensed in your state, ideally one who does community association work. If there is truly no authority in the declaration, the usual remedies are a quiet title action or a suit to remove an invalid lien, and several states impose penalties for recording a wrongful lien. - Ask about your state specifically. Some states have statutes drawing a clear line between mandatory and voluntary associations, and some require an association to opt in to mandatory status by recorded amendment approved by owners. One warning, and take it seriously. Do not simply refuse to pay at the closing table without counsel already engaged. A blown closing usually costs far more than the disputed dues: a lost buyer, a lost rate lock, and a second trip to market with a stale listing. The better play is often to close with the disputed amount held in escrow while the dispute gets resolved, if your attorney and the title company agree. I am Zoltan Peresztegi, a real estate professional based on the Palos Verdes Peninsula and working across the South Bay and greater Los Angeles. I am not an attorney, this is general information rather than legal advice, and association law varies a great deal by state. But the question to put in front of a lawyer is narrow: show me the recorded provision. Everything follows from the answer. Zoltan

Juan PicosReal Estate Agent4 months ago

If the recorded covenants truly do not authorize mandatory dues or transfer fees, that raises a legal issue that goes beyond a real estate transaction. Real estate agents and title companies generally rely on information provided by the HOA/POA, recorded governing documents, and title records. They typically do not have the authority to create or enforce fees that aren't legally supported. If there is a dispute over whether the dues or transfer fees are valid, that should be resolved by reviewing the recorded covenants, bylaws, and applicable state law. If you believe buyers and sellers are being given incorrect information, I recommend consulting a real estate attorney. An attorney can review the governing documents, determine whether the fees are enforceable, and advise on the appropriate legal steps to challenge the association or request that inaccurate information be corrected. **Juan Picos** REALTOR® | JohnHart Real Estate Serving Burbank, Glendale & Greater Los Angeles

Loodmy JacquesReal Estate Agent6 months ago

An agent or management company can’t just enforce fees because the POA says so. The authority needs to be in the recorded covenants or governing documents. Put it in writing and ask the POA, management company, agents, and title companies to show the recorded document that makes the dues or transfer fees mandatory. If they can’t prove it, talk to a real estate attorney. A demand letter from an attorney will usually carry more weight than arguing with the board or agents directly.

Kevin NeelyReal Estate Agent7 months ago

An agent cannot enforce payment of HOA dues that are clearly non-mandatory, but the question is worth examining carefully because HOA membership status is not always as simple as it sounds. In Tennessee and throughout the Southeast, some neighborhoods have voluntary property owners associations (POAs) where membership and dues are optional because the association was never properly established as a mandatory covenant. In other cases, dues appear voluntary but the recorded deed restrictions actually do make them mandatory, and a buyer or seller who has not read the governing documents might incorrectly assume otherwise. If you are disputing whether POA dues are actually mandatory, the first step is to pull the recorded deed restrictions, subdivision plat, and any declaration of covenants from the county records and read them carefully. If the documents clearly do not create a mandatory membership obligation, no party, including a real estate agent, has legal authority to require you to pay dues at closing. If there is ambiguity, a real estate attorney can interpret the documents and give you a clear answer. Agents who pressure buyers or sellers to pay questionable association fees should be asked to provide the specific recorded document that creates the obligation. Kevin Neely & Kaitlynd Robbins | K2 Sells

Barrett HenryReal Estate Agent7 months ago

This is a legal dispute that needs a real estate attorney, not a real estate agent's opinion. If your covenants genuinely do not include mandatory dues and the POA board and management company are fabricating obligations that don't exist in the recorded documents, you have a strong legal case. The covenants are the governing document, and anything the board or management company adds through bylaws that contradicts the covenants is likely unenforceable. Hire a real estate attorney who specializes in HOA and POA law in your state to review your covenants, the bylaws, and the actions the management company has taken. If the attorney confirms the dues aren't mandatory, they can send a cease-and-desist letter to the management company and the POA board, and notify the local title companies and real estate brokerages that the transfer fees and mandatory dues are not supported by the covenants. If multiple property owners in your community are affected, consider organizing and splitting the cost of legal representation. A single attorney letter on behalf of a group of homeowners carries more weight than individual complaints.

Amanda CourtneyReal Estate Agent1 year ago

No, an agent can’t enforce payment for a non-mandatory POA, but they can help clarify whether the association is truly voluntary or not. Sometimes joining a POA gives access to community benefits like amenities, landscaping, or maintenance that can help resale value later. Always review the community’s governing documents before deciding.

Julianne ClarkReal Estate Agent2 years ago

Sounding like you and your frustrated neighbors need to consult legal advice through a local real estate attorney familiar with the area, community and has handled closings in the community. I can understand your frustration and really do not think you will get the answer you are looking for on this forum. To many unknown variables and all states have different laws pertaining to property management.

Related Questions

Getting my name on my husband and my mortgage title.

Asked by 9096573743 | 91730 | 16 views | Finance & Legal Info | 11-11-2026 | Updated 3 days ago

Borrowing money to pay off my mortgage

Asked by Elwood Howard | Upper Darby | 24 views | Finance & Legal Info | 11-08-2026 | Updated 6 days ago

My parents left me there house

Asked by Shaun blake | 45205 | 17 views | Finance & Legal Info | 10-31-2026 | Updated 1 week ago

What fees can a realotor subtract from the original selling price?

Asked by Rachelle Ikerd | Visalia, CA | 29 views | Finance & Legal Info | 10-28-2026 | Updated 2 weeks ago

How do I get a home out of foreclosure?

Asked by Thad | San Diego, CA | 2,174 views | Finance & Legal Info | 02-05-2025 | Updated 3 weeks ago